Trade barriers alone unlikely to pole vault domestic manufacturing

23 November 2017 |

The Directorate General of Anti-Dumping and Allied Duty (DGAD) is currently completing an investigation into imports of solar cells and modules from China, Taiwan and Malaysia subsequent to a petition filed by The Indian Solar Manufacturer’s Association (ISMA). The petition is similar to an earlier petition filed in 2012, wherein DGAD had recommended an anti-dumping duty of USD 0.11-0.81/Wp on cells and modules but the Ministry of Finance ultimately decided to not impose any duties to protect downstream project development activity.

This time around, the industry is almost unanimously of the view that an anti-dumping duty will be announced soon as the government is keen to support local manufacturing. But the government still faces a dilemma as to how to balance the needs of solar manufacturers vs project developers and investors?

First, we should assess if the imposition of anti-dumping duty will provide the envisioned boost to domestic manufacturing? The Chinese manufacturers dominate Indian market because their products are about 10% cheaper than Indian counterparts. Most of the Indian manufacturers have sub-scale capacities, high cost base and are completely reliant on imported technology and raw materials. High cost of capital and electricity, poor infrastructure and lack of domestic eco-system means that the odds are stacked against them. Trade barriers may provide short-term relief but are unlikely to change long-term competitiveness of domestic manufacturers. That is why many leading Indian and international companies including Welspun, Sterling & Wilson, Trina Solar, Longi Solar, JA Solar etc have examined setting up manufacturing capacity in India but ultimately decided against it. Despite ten-fold growth in domestic demand in the last four years, Adani is the only new player to make a notable greenfield manufacturing investment so far.

Actual domestic production of modules and cells in FY 2016-17 was a mere 1,746 MW and 591 MW as against total demand of 9,188 MW. Though duties should provide existing domestic manufacturers with an opportunity to grow sales at profitable prices, the key question is whether India will be able to attract enough investments to create a thriving solar manufacturing sector. The European Union and USA have both imposed various protectionist measures in the past, but imports have kept rising and domestic manufacturing has not taken off. The Chinese have been expanding internationally and may be able to circumvent duties by routing exports from other locations.

As per our analysis, if anti-dumping duty is announced in the near future, it will impact about 10,000 MW of pipeline projects. Imposition of 30% duty will increase project cost by about 18%. Developers, already struggling with price rises due to GST and import duties, have no room to absorb additional costs. Unless these projects are grandfathered or the DISCOMs are willing to renegotiate PPAs, the risk of project abandonment for many of these projects is very high. The sector is already reeling from a slowdown in new project procurement and petition has increased uncertainty about the future of upcoming tenders.

The government faces a tough task of striking a right balance between the ambitious ‘National Solar Mission’ and ‘Make in India’ initiative. In our opinion, the imposition of anti-dumping duty will significantly disrupt the former without giving any material impetus to the latter.

Please read our full report on anti-dumping duty and its impact on different stakeholders.


Recent reports

Solar Manufacturing Prospects   

Buoyed by government promises of customs duty on imports and financial incentives, solar manufacturing sector is witnessing renewed interest....

Buy Report Download Executive Summary

India Solar Rooftop Map | June 2020

India’s operational rooftop solar capacity reached 5,953 MW as on 30 June 2020. Only 1,140 MW capacity is estimated to have been added in the twelve...

Download

India Renewable Map | June 2020

India’s utility scale solar and wind capacity reached 69,808 MW as on 30 June 2020. Only 6,284 MW of new capacity was added over last 12 months, dow...

Download

India Solar Compass Q2 2020   

India added just 351 MW of solar power generation capacity in Q2 2020 taking total installed capacity to 38,377 MW by 30 June 2020....

Buy Report Download Executive Summary

Transmission planning, implementation and status   

Transmission remains a critical bottleneck to growth of India’s renewable power sector....

Buy Report Download Executive Summary

India Renewable Power CEO Survey | 2020

The survey provides a sector-wide glimpse into the minds of renewable power leaders on industry outlook, capacity addition over the next 5 years, oper...

Download
Award winnig research
We use cookies to offer you an optimal user experience and collect information on website usage.