Loading...

Wind sector hobbled by soaring costs, unrealistic bids


25 April 2022 | BRIDGE TO INDIA

Wind sector hobbled by soaring costs, unrealistic bids

India added only 1,033 MW wind power generation capacity in 2021, down 14% YOY, taking total wind capacity to 40,709 MW. This is the fourth straight year of decline in capacity addition after competitive auctions replaced feed-in tariff regime in 2017. Out of total allocated capacity of 12.4 GW for vanilla wind projects in the last five years, only 4.3 GW capacity has been commissioned so far. About 3.2 GW capacity has been surrendered voluntarily by project developers on various grounds under SECI tenders. Total remaining pipeline of vanilla wind projects is estimated at 4.9 GW.

Figure: Wind power capacity addition, MW

Source: BRIDGE TO INDIA research

Project completion track record continues to remain extremely poor for multiple reasons. Most importantly, significant cost hikes across the whole value chain and severe land/ ROW availability issues have rendered almost all under construction projects unviable. As a result of increase in metal and other input costs, total EPC cost has surged by 15-20% over the last year alone to about INR 70 million/ MW. The turbine suppliers, faced with increasing cost and execution risks, have been reporting losses over last few years. Consequently, they have resorted to higher prices and derisking of the business by switching from lumpsum EPC model to simple equipment supply model. The Indian manufacturers are in particularly deep financial trouble with many of them partly or wholly shutting down plants.

The project developers are, therefore, having to procure other components and services – project design, land, erection and commissioning, and transmission – piecemeal in many cases further increasing execution cost and risk. Unviable bid tariffs have forced the developers to delay or surrender projects. Some of the largest developers have cited reasons like increased capex, unavailability of land, force majeure etc. while surrendering projects. Average commissioning timeline for projects under initial SECI tenders was 36 months from date of auction. But progress has substantially deteriorated for projects awarded since 2018 onwards (see chart below).

Figure: Commissioning status for wind projects under SECI tenders

Source: BRIDGE TO INDIA research
Note: Dates in this chart represent dates of auction for respective tenders.

Unfortunately, cost pressures and land issues are expected to persist in the foreseeable future. SECI has so far taken a pliant view of project delays and given multiple time extensions to project developers on account of COVID and land/ ROW issues. But we believe that with sub-three INR tariffs being sub-optimal in most cases, many more projects are likely to be abandoned.

Such poor progress of wind sector is a cause for alarm. The role of wind power, as a complementary technology for solar power, cannot be understated. It is critical for balancing the grid and meeting India’s lofty climate targets. The government ought to undertake holistic assessment of the sector as well as the competitive bidding framework to unlock growth. More specifically, the tenders should have adequate safeguards against unrealistic bids and punishing errant bidders.


Recent reports

Net Zero Roadmap for Corporates in India

Net Zero Roadmap for Corporates in India

The role of corporate entities, responsible for around half of India’s total energy consumption, is vital in meeting decarbonisation targets. Corporate entities are increasingly facing pressure from policy makers, consumers and investors to take climate action and define a roadmap for complete decarbonisation. Figure: Different sources of industrial emissions, 2016 Source:...

India Solar Map | December 2022

India Solar Map | December 2022

India Solar Map 2022 is an infographic report providing a state-wise break up of utility scale solar commissioned and pipeline capacity beside many other useful data points including project auction results, leading players, power generation, EPC cost, domestic module availability and power trading prices.

India Corporate Renewable Brief | Q4 2022

India Corporate Renewable Brief | Q4 2022

This report provides a quarterly update on key trends and developments in the corporate renewable market including capacity addition, key players, policy issuances, financing, equipment prices and other market trends. Figure: Total C&I renewable capacity, MW Source: BRIDGE TO INDIA research India added 1,093 MW corporate renewable capacity in Q4 2022, down 14% QOQ. Total...

India PV Module Intelligence Brief | Q4 2022

India PV Module Intelligence Brief | Q4 2022

This report captures quarterly trends in module demand and supply, import and domestic production volumes, supplier market shares, break-up by technology and rating, pricing trends across the value chain and key international developments. Figure: Domestic module shipments, Q4 2022 Q4 saw capacity addition of 2,755 MW, down 17% over the previous quarter. Total module demand in the...

India Solar Compass | Q4 2022

India Solar Compass | Q4 2022

This report provides a detailed update of all key sector developments and trends in the quarter – capacity addition, leading players, tenders and policy announcements, equipment prices, financial deals and other market developments. It also provides market outlook for the next two quarters. Total installed and pipeline capacity by offtake, 31 December 2022, MW Source: BRIDGE TO INDIA...

India Corporate Renewable Market

India Corporate Renewable Market

India’s corporate renewable market is becoming more vibrant with strong demand, policy and technology levers. Driven by net zero targets and investor mandates, corporate consumers are rushing to adopt more renewable power. Despite policy resistance in many states and huge cost pressure, annual installations grew by 125% in 2022. Total installed renewables capacity is expected to grow from...

To top